Alcuin
This article is about the scholar Alcuin of York. For the University of York college, see Alcuin College |
Rabanus Maurus (left), supported by Alcuin (middle), presents his work to Otgar of Mainz |
Flaccus Albinus Alcuinus or
Ealhwine (c.
735-
May 19,
804) was a scholar and teacher from
York, England. He was born in an unknown year in a place close to Yorkâ€"perhaps in the city itself. He was a noble, related to
Saint Willibrord whose father founded the monastery of
St. Andrew which Alcuin would later inherit.
Alcuin of York had a long career as a teacher and scholar first at the school at York (now known as
St Peter's School, York, founded AD
627) and lastly as
Charlemagne's leading advisor on ecclesiastical and educational affairs. From
796 until his death he was
abbot of the great
monastery of
St. Martin of Tours.
He was brought to the cathedral school of York in the golden age of
Egbert and
Eadbert.
Egbert had been a disciple of the Venerable
Bede who urged him to have
York raised to an
archbishopric.
Eadbert was the king and brother to
Egbert. These two men oversaw the reenergizing and reorganization of the
English church with an emphasis on reforming the clergy and on the tradition of learning begun under
Bede. Alcuin thrived under
Egbert's tutelage who loved him especially. It was in
York that he formed his love of classical poetry, though he was sometimes troubled by the fact that it was written by non-Christians.
The
York school was renowned as a center of learning not only in religious matters but in the liberal arts, literature and science named
the seven liberal arts.
It was here that Alcuin would become a man and from which he most certainly would draw the inspiration for the school he would lead at the
Frankish court. While reviving school with such disciplines as the
trivium and the
quadrivium two codices were written in that instance, the first on the trivium, written by himself, and the second on the quadrivium, by his student,
Hraban.
Alcuin graduated from student to teacher sometime in the 750s. His ascendancy to the headship of the
York school began after
Aelbert became Archbishop of York in 767. It is around this same time that Alcuin became a deacon in the church. Alcuin would not be ordained a priest and there is no real evidence that he became an actual monk, though he lived his life like one.
In 781, King
Elfwald sent Alcuin to
Rome to petition the
Pope for official confirmation of York's status as an archbishopric and to confirm the election of a new archbishop,
Eanbald I. It was then, on his way home, that Alcuin met
Charles, king of the
Franks.
Alcuin was reluctantly persuaded to join
Charles's court. His love of the church and his intellectual curiosity made the offer one he could not refuse. He was to join an already illustrious group of scholars that Charles had gathered around him like
Peter of Pisa,
Paulinus,
Rado, and
Abbot Fulrad. He would later write that "the Lord was calling me to the service of King Charles."
Alcuin was welcomed at the Palace School of
Charlemagne. The school had been founded under the king's ancestors as a place for educating the royal children, mostly in manners and the ways of the court. King
Charles wanted more, he wanted the
liberal arts and, most importantly, the study of the religion he held sacred.
Charlemagne was a master of gathering the best men of every nation at his court and becoming more than just the king at the center. It seems that
Charlemagne made many of these men his closest friends and counselors. They referred to him as
David, a reference to the Biblical king. Alcuin soon found himself on intimate terms with the king and with the other men at court to whom he gave nicknames to be used for work and play. Like many of his learnéd contemporaries, Alcuin was an
astrologer.
David Berlinski, author of
The Secrets of the Vaulted Sky: Astrology and the Art of Prediction (ISBN 0151005273) writes: "The ninth-century philosopher Alcuin, his voyages to the
Middle East now abrogated, was an
astrological adept, and it is widely claimed that he taught
Charlemagne the principles of
classical astrology" (pg. 116, 2003).
Alcuin's friendships also extended to the ladies of the court, especially the queen mother and the daughters of the king. His relationships with these women, however, never reached the intense level of those with the men around him.
From
782 to
790, Alcuin had as pupils the king of the Franks, his kinsmen, the young men sent for their education to the court, and the young
clerics attached to the palace chapel; he was the life and soul of the Academy of the palace, and we have still, in the
Dialogue of Pepin (son of Charlemagne) and Alcuin, a sample of the intellectual exercises in which they indulged. One surviving tool of the drive to reform
education is
Charlemagne's circular letter
De Litteris Colendis, "On the Study of Letters", which Alcuin wrote.
A sample from the "Dialogue":
Pepin Albinus (Alcuin)
1. What is writing? The guardian of history.
2. What is speech? The revealer of spirit.
3. What gives birth to speech? The tongue.
4. What is the tongue? The lash of the air.
5. What is air? The guardian of life.
6. What is life? The joy of the blessed, the sorrow
of the sad, the looking for death.
Later, a riddle:
89. I saw the dead give birth to the living, and the alive consumed unto death by the living's wrath.
In
790 Alcuin went back to England, to which he had always been greatly attached, and dwelt there for some time; but
Charlemagne invited him back to help in the fight against the
Adoptionist heresy, which was at that time making great progress in Toledo
Spain, the old capital town of the
Visigoths and still a major city for the Christians under Islamic rule in Spain. He is believed to have had contacts with
Beatus of Liébana, from the
Kingdom of Asturias, who fought against Adoptionism. At the
Council of Frankfurt in
794, Alcuin upheld the
orthodox doctrine, and obtained the condemnation of the
heresiarch Felix of Urgel. After this victory he again went back to England, but on account of the disturbances which broke out there, and which led to the death of King Aethelred of Northumbria (
796), he left it forever.
In 796 Alcuin was in his sixties. He hoped to be free from court duties and was given the chance when
Abbot Itherius of
Tours died. King
Charles gave the abbey to Alcuin with the understanding that he should be available if the king ever needed his counsel.
He made the abbey school into a model of excellence, and many students flocked to it; he had many manuscripts copied, the
calligraphy of which is of outstanding beauty. He wrote many letters to his friends in England, to
Arno, bishop of Salzburg, and above all to
Charlemagne. These letters, of which 311 are extant, are filled mainly with pious meditations, but they further form a mine of information as to the literary and social conditions of the time, and are the most reliable authority for the history of
humanism in the
Carolingian age. He also trained the numerous monks of the abbey in piety, and it was in the midst of these pursuits that he died.
Alcuin is the most prominent figure of the
Carolingian Renaissance, in which three main periods have been distinguished: in the first of these, up to the arrival of Alcuin at the court, the
Italians occupy the central place; in the second, Alcuin and the
Anglo-Saxons are dominant; in the third, which begins in
804, the influence of the
Visigoth Theodulf is preponderant.
We owe to him, too, some manuals used in his educational work; a
grammar and works on
rhetoric and
dialectics. They are written in the form of
dialogues, and in the two last the interlocutors are
Charlemagne and Alcuin. He also wrote several
theological treatises: a
De fide Trinitatis, commentaries on the
Bible, etc.
Alcuin transmitted to the
Franks the knowledge of Latin culture which had existed in England. We still have a number of his works. His letters have already been mentioned; his
poetry is equally interesting. Besides some graceful epistles in the style of
Fortunatus, he wrote some long poems, and notably a whole history in verse of the church at York:
Versus de patribus, regibus et sanctis Eboracensis ecclesiae.
Among the most interesting extant writing of Alcuin is his poetry. Recent scholarship suggests that Alcuin may have been
homosexually inclined if not in actions that certainly emotionally. He and his circle of men and boys looked to the classical for inspiration. They traded in classically allusive and affectionate nicknames for each other as well as trading what can only be classified as love poetry in some instances. They copied such poets as
Virgil and his
Eclogues which famously focused on the bond of male friendship and celebrated the beauty of the young male.
A tradition reemerged at this time that celebrated male bonds of love.
Medieval ideas of male friendship as on a higher plane than the relationship between a man and his wife reached back to church fathers like
Augustine and
Aquinas. And, it cannot be assumed that all poetry of this sort written at the time was written by homosexuals.
Abelard, famously heterosexual, wrote of the love between men.
Thomas Stehling wrote that, "to receive and education and to learn to read and write in the middle ages meant entering the church and living in a community of men who had forsaken the idea of marriage, though not necessarily all sexual activity." These men formed strong emotional bonds of love and friendship on all levels which they expressed through letters and poems.
We must be clear to not put too much of a 20th century conception of
homosexuality onto
medieval lives. There was no such distinction. There were
homosexual actsâ€"the sin of engaging in
sodomy. However, a man who loved another man, whether or not they engaged in the sex act, would not have been condemned. We cannot know if Alcuin ever had sex with another man, but his poetry makes certain that it is a distinct possibility. Late in life he would seek redemption for certain acts of his past that he would not name but that he felt certain were well-known and about which he thought he might be punished.
The following is one such poem. As stated above, we can never know what happened between the author, Alcuin, and the recipient. Yet, it is clearly a statement of love, homosexual love, deep love.
Alcuin, To
Arno of Salzburg Love has penetrated my heart with its flame,
And is ever rekindled with new warmth.
Neither sea nor land, hills nor forest, nor even Alps,
Can stand in its way or hinder it
From always licking at your inmost parts, good father,
Or from bathing your heart, my beloved, with tears.
Sweet love, why do you inspire bitter tears,
Why do bitter draughts flow from devotion's honey?
If now your sweetness, world, is mixed with bitterness,
All prosperity will alternate rapidly with misfortune
All joys be changed to sad lamentation;
Nothing lasts, anything can perish.
Therefore, world, let us flee from you with all our hearts,
As you, ready even now to perish, flee from us.
Let us seek the delights and ever-enduring realms
Of heaven with our whole heart, mind, and hand.
The blessed hall of heaven never separates friends;
A heart warmed by love will never be estranged.
Look with joy and with a gladdening heart, I pray,
At these little offerings which great love sends you,
For our gentle Master praised the two copper coins
The needy widow put into the temple's treasury.
Sacred love is better than any gift,
And so is steadfast faithfulness which flourishes and endures.
May divine gifts follow you, dearest father,
And at the same time precede you. Always and
Everywhere farewell.
Alcuin died on 19 May 804, some ten years before the emperor. He was buried at St. Martin's church under an epitaph that party read:
Dust, worms, and ashes now …
Alcuin my name, wisdom I always loved,
Pray, reader, for my soul.
Alcuin College, part of the
University of York, is named after him.
Alcuin and the Rise of the Christian Schools by Andrew Fleming West ISBN 083711635X
Alcuin, Friend of Charlemagne, Eleanor Shipley Duckett, 1951
Carolingian Portraits, Eleanor Shipley Duckett, 1962
The Carolingians and the Frankish Monarchy, F. L. Ganshof, ISBN 0582482275
Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality, John Boswell, ISBN 0226067106
Friendship, and Community: The Monastic Experience, Brian P. McGuire, ISBN 0879078952
Medieval Latin Love Poems of Male Love and Friendship, Thomas Stehling
Poetry of the Carolingian Renaissance, Peter Godman, ISBN 0715617680
*