Carbine
This article is about the term "carbine" in relation to firearms. For information on the racehorse with the same name, see Carbine (horse). For the chemistry term, see carbene.A
carbine is a
firearm similar to, but generally shorter and less powerful than, a
rifle or
musket of a given period. There have been many carbines developed from rifles, being essentially shorter rifles firing the same
ammunition, although usually at a lower
velocity, and there have also been many where the carbine and rifle adopted by a particular nation were not technically related, such as using completely different ammunition or internal operating systems (though the carbine still being weaker, or of smaller size). Which may be more common depends on the time period.
In the 1800s, carbines were generally smaller firearms for
troops that rode on horses. The
foot soldiers would have a longer, more powerful firearm, and cavalry a shorter, lighter firearm. The shorter length and lighter weight of carbines makes them easier to handle in close-quarter combat situations (such as
urban or
jungle warfare), or when deploying from
vehicles. The disadvantages of carbines, when compared with their longer counterparts, are generally poorer long-range accuracy and shorter effective
range.
Early history of the carbine: 1800s and earlier
The carbine was originally a lighter, shorter weapon developed for cavalry soldiers, for whom a full-length musket or rifle was too heavy and awkward to fire from horseback. Carbines were usually less accurate and powerful than the longer rifles of the infantry, due to a shorter
sight plane and lower velocity of bullets fired from the shortened barrel. With the advent of fast-burning
smokeless powder, the velocity disadvantages of the shorter barrels became less of an issue (see
internal ballistics). Eventually, the use of horse-mounted cavalry would decline, but carbines continued to be issued and used by many who preferred a lighter, more compact weapon even at the cost of reduced long-range accuracy and power. A shorter weapon was more convenient when riding on horses, but it was also more convenient when riding in a truck,
armored personnel carrier,
helicopter or aircraft, and also when engaged in close-range combat.
During the nineteenth century, carbines were often developed separately from the infantry rifles, and in many cases did not even use the same ammunition, which made for supply difficulties. A notable weapon developed towards the end of the
American Civil War by the Union was the
Spencer carbine. It had a spring powered
magazine in the stock which held seven rounds. In the late 1800s it became common for a number of nations to make
bolt-action rifles in both full-length and carbine versions. One of the most popular and recognizable carbines was the Winchester
lever-action carbine, with several versions using
revolver cartridges. This made it an ideal choice for
cowboys and explorers, who could carry a revolver and a carbine, both using the same ammunition.
Shorter rifles, shorter carbines: World War I and World War II
In the decades preceding
World War I, the standard battle rifle used by armies around the world had been growing shorter, either by redesign or by the general issue of carbine versions instead of full-length rifles. For example, the Russian Model 1891 rifle with a 31.5 inch (800 mm) barrel was shortened to 28.75 in. (730 mm) in 1930, and to 20 in. (510 mm) in 1938; the German
Mauser 98 rifles went from 29 in. (740 mm) in 1898 to 23.6 in. (600 mm) in 1935 as the
Karabiner Kurz (K98k), or "short carbine". The barrel lengths in rifles used by the
United States did not change between the
bolt-action M1903 rifle of
World War I and the
World War II M1 Garand rifle, but then the 24 in. (610 mm) barrel on the M1903 was short for its day. The US
M1 Carbine was more of a traditional carbine in that it was significantly shorter and lighter, with an 18 in. barrel (460 mm), than the M1 Garand rifle. The M1 Carbine was not a shorter version of the
M1 Garand, but a wholly different design firing a smaller, less-powerful cartridge, as was common in the 1800s.
Post-World War II
Based on the combat experience of WWII, the criteria used for selecting infantry weapons began to change. Unlike previous wars, which were often fought mainly from fixed lines and trenches, WWII was a highly mobile war, often fought in cities, forests, or other areas where mobility and visibility were restricted. In addition, improvements in
artillery made moving infantry in open areas even more suicidal than it had been.
The majority of enemy contacts were at ranges of less than 300 meters (325 yards), and the enemy was exposed to fire for only short periods of time as they moved from cover to cover. Most rounds fired were not aimed at an enemy combatant, but instead fired in the enemy's direction to keep them from moving and firing back (see
suppressive fire). These situations did not require a heavy rifle, firing full-power rifle bullets with long-range accuracy. A less-powerful weapon would still produce casualties at the shorter ranges encountered in actual combat, and the reduced recoil would allow more shots to be fired in the short amount of time an enemy was visible. The lower-powered round would also weigh less, allowing a soldier to carry more ammunition. With no need of a long barrel to fire full-power ammunition, a shorter barrel could be used. A shorter barrel made the weapon weigh less and was easier to handle in tight spaces, and was easier to shoulder quickly to fire a shot at an unexpected target.
Full-automatic fire was also considered a desirable feature, allowing the soldier to fire short bursts of three to five rounds, increasing the probability of a hit on a moving target.
The Germans had experimented with
selective-fire carbines firing rifle cartridges during the early years of WWII. These were determined to be less than ideal, as the recoil of full-power rifle cartridges caused the weapon to be uncontrollable in full-automatic fire. They then developed an intermediate-power cartridge round, which was accomplished by reducing the power and the length of the standard 7.92 x 57 mm rifle cartridge to create the 7.92 x 33 mm
Kurz (Short) cartridge. A selective-fire weapon was developed to fire this shorter cartridge, eventually resulting in the
Sturmgewehr 44, later translated as "
assault rifle". After WWII, the USSR would adopt a similar weapon, the well-known
AK-47, which became the standard Soviet infantry weapon. The United States during WWII also had the
M2 Carbine, a selective-fire version of the
M1 Carbine firing a 7.62x33mm cartridge. However, the semi-automatic M1 carbine was produced in a 10-to-1 ratio to the M2.
Although the
NATO countries did not adopt an intermediate-power round, they continued the trend toward shorter and lighter
magazine-fed
battle rifles. NATO adopted the
7.62 x 51 mm NATO round (which in reality is only slightly less powerful than the
.30-06 Springfield and more powerful than the
.303 British) along with several rifles such as the
FN FAL and
M14.
By the 1960s NATO had adopted the
5.56 x 45 mm NATO cartridge. This round was even lighter and smaller than the Soviet AK-47 cartridge, but possessed higher velocity and roughly the same muzzle energy. In U.S. service, the
M16 assault rifle replaced the M14 as the standard
infantry weapon, although the M14 continued to be used by
designated marksmen.
Lighter carbines came to be adopted as the standard infantry long rifle. What changed was that only a certain number of soldiers now needed to retain longer range weapons, serving as designated marksmen. Development of lighter assault rifles continued, matched by developments in even lighter carbines. At the same time the infantry switched to 5.56 mm weapons, carbines like the
AK74SU (which fired a Warsaw pact
5.45 x 39 mm round) and
CAR 15 were being developed.
Carbine use in contemporary military forces
By the 1990s, the US had adopted the M4 Carbine, a derivative of the M16 family which was lighter and shorter (in overall length and barrel length), resulting in reduced range and power. In addition, due to the development of
body armor, support personnel required a compact weapon with more stopping power than the traditional
pistol, leading to the development of the
personal defense weapon, or PDW, which uses rounds that have better
ballistics than simple pistol rounds but less power and range than full rifle rounds. Examples include the
FN P90 and
HK MP7. Whether these ultra-light weapons will be widely adopted has yet to be seen; in particular, it is questionable whether their stopping power is adequate. The cartridge used by the FN P90, the
5.7 x 28 mm, for example, fires a 30 grain (1.9 g) armor piercing bullet at velocities of around 2300 ft/s (700 m/s). This gives similar ballistics to the high velocity loadings in the
.22 Winchester Magnum Rimfire round, which is generally considered wholly inadequate for defensive use. The H&K MP7 fires an even smaller 4.6 mm round with ballistics similar to the .22 WMR derived
.17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire. The small diameter rounds enable the projectile to travel at the high velocity needed to penetrate
kevlar armor, as a light weapon with sufficient energy to push a large caliber bullet through the armor would have prohibitive recoil. The small bullets, however, do not have much wounding power. They are generally designed to tumble after penetration, and while that works in theory, other tumbling rounds such as the
5.56 x 45 mm and the
5.45 x 39 mm have shown erratic performance in the field (see below).
Meanwhile, many armies are experiencing a backlash against carbines and lighter rifles in general, and are equipping selected soldiers, usually called
Designated Marksman, or DM, with higher power rifles. While firing more smaller bullets makes it easier to hit a target, and is good for beginner marksmen, it offers very little to more advanced marksmen. In addition, the additional range of the heavier weapons has proven to be necessary in open environments such as deserts. As a result, the focus on more highly trained soldiers equipped with, for example, 7.62 mm NATO firing rifles, such as the
U.S. Marine Corps Designated Marksman Rifle variant of the
M14, has increased somewhat. A squad of soldiers armed with assault rifles would have a single soldier assigned as DM who would carry a battle rifle for selectively engaging long range targets. The DM differs from the sniper in that the DM is highly mobile, moving with his unit, and engages targets at ranges beyond the 300 metre (330 yd) effective range of modern assault rifles, but less than the 600 metre (650 yd) range which is the optimal engagement range for snipers.
Special operations forces
One bastion of the carbine which is unlikely to be unseated is the special operations forces of the world. Because of the need to perform fast, decisive operations, a pistol is viewed as not having enough power. A pistol is conversely very light, and aids in the speed of the operator. Consequently, carbines have gained wide acceptance among
SOCOM and other communities. An example of this would be the Springfield Armory SOCOM 16, which is a 16 in (406 mm) barreled carbine chambered in
.308 Winchester (7.62 NATO). With a composite stock and lighter parts, as well as increased sight aperture or
ACOG, the rifle maintains a high degree of accuracy for
close quarters battle, as well as being serviceable to ranges up to 400 yards (370 m). The rifle maintains light weight, and has far superior stopping power to most pistol cartridges. Additionally, with 20 and 30 round magazines, the firepower is dramatically preferable to a pistol.
Personal defense weapons
In both civilian use and among the military's lighter armored soldiers, it is common to use a carbine. However, due to some of the reasons mentioned elsewhere in this article, such as muzzle blast and recoil, these carbines are generally chambered in lighter rounds than some of their heavier (or shorter) counterparts. Due to the low wounding power of a single round, personal defense weapons depend on high volumes of fire for effectiveness. This may make such carbines successful in military use. In civilian use, where fully automatic fire is impractical or illegal, and shot placement is more critical, acceptance may be lower, as a pistol involves single shots. However, firing a pistol effectively at any significant range requires good training, since the absence of a buttstock makes precise ranged aim difficult.
Future acceptance and use
To what extent armies will adopt even lighter carbines, and to what extent they will be avoided, has yet to be seen entirely. It is likely that harder hitting, or at least higher penetrating, weapons will become more common, due to a rise in use of body armor, making weaker weapons ineffective. Stacked against this is mainly the amount of urban warfare that is required, which favors lighter carbine weapons.
The modern usage of the term carbine covers much the same scope as it always had, namely lighter weapons (generally rifles) with barrels of less than about 18 inches (460 mm). These weapons can be considered carbines, while rifles with barrels of 20 inches (510 mm) or more are generally not considered carbines unless specifically named so, and depending on the weapon's power. Modern carbines are chambered in calibers from pistol calibers to full power rifle cartridges, usually up to, but not including, the high velocity magnum rifle cartridges. In the more powerful cartridges, the short barrel of a carbine has significant disadvantages in velocity, and the high residual pressure when the bullet exits the barrel results in substantially greater
muzzle blast.
Flash suppressors and
muzzle brakes are common solutions to this problem, which may ease their acceptance.
For military and security forces there is emerging a wide range of less than lethal PDW options. These range from
tasers to microwave beam type weapons.
Pistol caliber carbines
One of the more unusual classes of carbine is the pistol caliber carbine. These first appeared soon after metallic cartridges became common. These were developed as "companions" to the popular
revolvers of the day, firing the same cartridge but allowing more velocity and accuracy than the revolver. These were carried by
cowboys, lawmen, and others in the
Old West. The classic combination would be a
Winchester lever action carbine and a
Colt revolver in .44-40 or .45 Colt.
Modern equivalents also exist, such as the
Ruger Police Carbine, which uses the same magazine as the Ruger
pistols of the same caliber. The
Beretta Cx4 Storm shares magazines with many
Beretta pistols, and shares its design with the
Beretta Px4 Storm pistol. The recent introduction of such products may indicate that there is a growing demand for these companion carbines.
The primary advantage of a pistol caliber carbine, other than the usually-added buttstock or shoulder rest for increased accuracy, is the fact that in general a longer barrel will yield higher projectile velocity. This results in greater stopping power and increased ability to penetrate body armor. Additionally, many pistol calibers, such as .45 ACP, have much heavier projectiles, such as 230 grain (15 g), than rifles do, 55 grains (3.6 g) being common in 22-caliber rounds like .22-250 and .223.
Recently, kits have appeared on the market which consist of a carbine length barrel, bolt (usually
blowback operated), and stock that attach to a pistol frame. Attaching the pistol frame provides the feed mechanism (through the pistol's magazine) and trigger mechanism, and produces a completed carbine. Kits of this type are available for Colt
M1911 pattern and
GLOCK pistols.
Short barrelled rifles
Firearms with shoulder stocks and barrels less than 16 in (406 mm) in length are classified as "short barreled rifles" (under the US
National Firearms Act or
NFA), and are sometimes restricted in the same way that
sawed off shotguns and
machine guns are. Because of this, rifles with barrels of less than 16 in (406 mm), or pistols with shoulder stocks, are rare. A list of firearms not covered by the NFA due to their antique or
Curio and Relic status may be found here[
1]; this list includes a number of carbines with barrels less than the minimum legal length. Firearms classified as
machine guns are also not subject to the barrel length restriction.
|
A Browning Hi-Power, made for the Finnish military, with attached shoulder stock |
Kits exist which will convert many pistols into carbines by the addition of a shoulder stock; notable examples are the long barrelled
Colt Buntline revolver stock, the
Mauser C96 "Broomhandle" holster/stock, and various others for models such as the
Browning Hi-Power,
Luger, Colt
M1911, and the
Heckler & Koch VP70. Since these stock additions retain the short pistol barrel (as short as 4 inches (10 cm)) they are highly restricted under the NFA; many pistols which had attachments for the stocks, including rare wartime models, were altered to remove the attachment point.
Air carbines
In the world of
airguns, there is a small but growing class of what are also called "ultra carbines", that have extremely short barrels. These may be rifles with barrels cut down to as short as 8 inches (203 mm), or pistols converted into carbines with the addition of a shoulder stocks. These are generally not restricted legally in the same way some firearms are.
Other carbines
Another class of carbine is a semi-automatic version of a
submachine gun, with an extended barrel, just over 16 inches (406 mm) long, which will escape ban by some "assault weapon" legislation. While functionally identical to other carbines, these are banned in some places as "assault weapons" based on their cosmetic similarity to submachine guns. However, they may not accept certain parts (such as magazines or collapsing stocks) from the submachine guns they resemble. These are a popular compromise for (American) shooters who would like to own a submachine gun but cannot due to local restrictions or the prohibitive cost of buying a civilian legal submachine gun (since the end of the
Clinton assault weapons ban, this has become less prohibitive). While these submachine gun lookalikes are acceptable for use for self defense, the media generally portrays them as being used for violent crime. As such, this may make them a poor choice for a personal defense weapon. This does not deter many of the more vocal proponents of personal defense firearms, who typically recommend a pistol and a higher power weapon, like a carbine or a
shotgun.
In some historical cases the term
machine carbine was the official title for sub-machine guns. Examples are the
Sten and
Owen guns. Equally to confuse the non-automatic version of the
Sterling submachine gun was also a "Carbine".
*
M1 Carbine*
M2 Carbine*
M3 Carbine*
M4 Carbine*
XM8 Carbine*
De Lisle carbine*
Kel-Tec SUB-2000
